March 24 - April 2, 2023

The Annex

Written by: Joseph Kesserling 

Directed by: Paula Ferguson

Produced by: Moulton L. Ferguson 

Thursdays, Fridays, & Saturdays: 7:30 PM

Sundays: 2:00 PM


Drama critic Mortimer Brewster’s engagement announcement is upended when he discovers a corpse in his elderly aunts’ window seat. Mortimer rushes to tell them before they stumble upon the body themselves. He learns that the two women aren’t just aware of the dead man, they killed him! Between his aunts’ penchant for poisoning wine, a brother who thinks he’s president, and another brother using plastic surgery to hide from the police – not to mention his own hesitancy about marriage, Arsenic and Old Lace is a classic comedy about the only thing more deadly than poison: family.



Arsenic and Old Lace is presented by special arrangement with Dramatists Play Services, Inc. 


Online Sales:

Online sales end approximately one hour prior to the start of the show.

By Phone:

Call Us: 724-654-3437

Visit the Box Office:

212 East Long Avenue, New Castle, PA

Hours: 10AM – 4 PM, Monday – Friday


Tina Greig — Abby Brewster

Cindy West — Martha Brewster

Phillip L. Clark, Jr. — Teddy Brewster

Brandon McCormick — Mortimer Brewster

Matthew Kingman — The Rev. Dr. Harper

Renee DiAlesandro — Elaine Harper

Robert Whiting — Jonathan Brewster

Eric Chevlen — Dr. Einstein

Mike Lyons — Officer O’Hara

Kelly Berie — Officer Brophy

Kristen Younger — Officer Klein

Harriet Lemberger Schor — Lieutenant Rooney

Walter Plinge — Mr. Witherspoon

George Spelvin — Mr. Gibbs