212 E. Long Ave

New Castle, PA 16101

Mon - Fri: 9:00 - 3:00

NCP Office

(724) 654-3437

Mon - Fri: 9:00 - 3:00


February 9 - 18, 2024

The Annex

Directed by: Michael Cavalier

Thursdays, Fridays, & Saturdays: 7:30 PM

Sundays: 2:00 PM


“Love Letters” unfolds as a captivating narrative chronicling the enduring friendship and evolving relationship between Andrew Makepeace Ladd III and Melissa Gardner. Beginning in childhood, the two characters embark on a journey through life’s triumphs and tribulations, using letters as their primary means of communication. The exchange of heartfelt, candid, and at times, poignant letters reveals the complexities of their connection, touching upon themes of love, loss, and the passage of time. From the innocence of youth to the challenges of adulthood, the letters serve as a window into the characters’ souls, allowing the audience to witness the profound impact they have on each other’s lives.


This show has been brought to life by nearly 60 distinguished performers on Broadway and Off-Broadway stages. To keep with tradition, our production promises not one, but TWO incredible casts!


February 9 -11

Melissa Gardner- Amy Warner

Andrew Makepeace Ladd III-  Robert S. Hazen


February 15-18

Melissa Gardner- Lynn Nelson Rafferty

Andrew Makepeace Ladd III- Phillip L. Clark Jr.

Romantic Weekend Giveaway Promotion:

Secure your tickets for ‘Love Letters’ and, during the show, make sure to visit our giveaway station. Complete your FREE ticket for a chance to win our Romantic Weekend Giveaway, featuring a $250 gift card to the Fairmont Hotel and a $100 gift card to Hyde Park Steakhouse in Pittsburgh.

To enter, attendance at the show is a must, and participants must be 21 years or older.


Roses are Red My Love Raffle :

This raffle runs on FRIDAYS – Feb. 9 & 16

Red Roses are the universal symbol of LOVE!  Each Friday, earn a chance to win a dozen of long stemmed roses courtesy of Posies By Patty in Ellwood City and T.B.A.


Cheesecake & Coffee Sundays:

This special runs on SUNDAYS – Feb. 11th & 18th 

“Cheesecake will always taste like LOVE” Join us on Sundays for a slice of your favorite cheesecake and cup coffee.  


  • February 11th – Cheesecake & Deep Dish Apple Crumb courtesy of Crystals Cakery in Ellwood City.
  • February 18th – Cheesecake & Apple Pie courtesy of Giant Eagle


Online Sales:

Online sales end approximately one hour prior to the start of the show.

By Phone:

Call Us: 724-654-3437

Visit the Box Office:

212 East Long Avenue, New Castle, PA

Hours: 9:00 AM – 3:00 PM, Monday – Friday